Marwan Bishara on Nakba's legacy: 'Israel might have won, but the Palestinians have never lost'

So well said Marvan bishara 👍💯Agree

I am white and born in Australia and feel great sorrow and shame for what is happening here. What is happening here is same as Australia{Britain} taking by force something which did not belong to them. Same thing America {Britain} did to indigenous peoples. Shame on you Britain and the USA and Australia. Australia "prides" itself on multiculturalism but will not stand up and be counted and speak up for the oppressed.😢 Shame on us... The civilized world. Free Palestine Free Julian Assange

As always, right on the money and so refreshing to hear Marwan’s perspective, analysis and insights.

I would sell all the political commentators here in Germany for one Marwan Bishara. In a heartbeat.

Thank you so much Mr. Marwan Bishara and Al Jazeera correspondent for the great analysis. ❤❤❤❤❤

Great journalism like always marawaan bashara i just love listening to him from South Africa

Netanyahu the war criminal must be behind bars Netanyahu is the most dangerous person on earth .from South Africa 🇿🇦

Israël maybe won a piece of land. But Palestine won the hearts of the world 🌎 ♥️

Today "Haaretz" has an excellent article about the Nakba, the Green Line, and how Israeli governments have systematically dehumanized Palestinians and erased Palestinian culture as part of the Jewish state's structural racism.

Israel didn't win anything, the resistance has never been so powerful

'Palestinians have paid the real price of Holocaust ' that hits hard. Yes, they weren't the party to it but have been paying for it since decades. It's NOT their fault for what happened in Germany.

I agree with Mr. Marwan 100%

I see Marwan, I click. Simple.

He is talking about Israel "winning" in the first Nakba by ethnically cleansing the Palestinians with no repercussions , he is not talking about them winning this current war. Don't feed the trolls.

Philippines 🇵🇭 and India 🇮🇳 are angry at china 🇨🇳 for occupying disputed territory but support Israel 🇮🇱 brutal occupation of Palestine 🇵🇸 Double standards from Philippines 🇵🇭 and India 🇮🇳 Free Palestine 🇵🇸

Marwan Bishara is a very good scholar

Much love and respect Marwan, AJ and Palestinians!❤💚🖤🤍❤The injustice is so cruel and heartless and it's difficult to understand why people in power can't put a stop to this brutality, but it brings me to the conclusion that they're simply unwilling, because they're all traitors, deceivers, liars, murderers etc etc. God will act until then I pray for strength, courage and wisdom to endure. (I'm so so sad today, I want this brutality to stop once and for all).

British mandate 1921 and Hagana forces committed killing and migrating Palestinian people to neighbouring countries for 27 years. The British army left Palestine 1948 after the UN 1948 approved the occupation of Palestine. Palestinian people have for hundred years endured unjust genocide by the occupation.

The war was between other Arab nations and US/UK backed Israel . Nakba was part of the reason why other Arab involved. But most of the Palestinians were not armed or militarized. So when these Arab nations decided to leave. They left these unarmed civilians basically at the mercy of Israel. The German should let the Jews take over Germany if they are so upset since it was them that caused the Holocaust. And US and UK cared so much they should give them a state to these Jews instead of giving a land Arabs lived on for thousand of years. Most of the modern day conflicts are result of seeds of division planted by the British Empire that became unavoidable outbreak of violent human nature under a diabolical situation. It was the same situation for partition of India. USA just inherited British ways to continue these efforts.

With the overwhelming evidence that the modern Jewish population is of Khazar origin, author Arthur Koestler remarks that this would clearly indicate that "their ancestors came not from the Jordan but from the Volga, not from Canaan but from the Caucasus, once believed to be the cradle of the Aryan race; and that genetically they are more closely related to the Hun, Uigur and Magyar tribes than to the seed of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob." This conclusion would then logically render the epithet "anti-Semitism" void of meaning, Koestler says.