Everything Wrong With Dune: Part 2 in 21 Minutes or Less
221,481
Published 2024-07-09
Dune Part 2 is awesome. But you know it has sins. Here are some we found.
For the most up-to-date info and happenings, visit: linktr.ee/cinemasins
We want to know more about you, so fill out this sinful poll - iter.ly/lvr9d - and consider supporting our small team at patreon.com/cinemasins.
•Writers•
Jeremy: twitter.com/cinemasins
Chris
Aaron: twitter.com/aarondicer
Jonathan: twitter.com/samloomis13
Deneé: twitter.com/DeneeSays
Ian: twitter.com/Whittsinned
Daniel: www.instagram.com/shakeydanspeare
•Other Links•
-Discord: discord.com/invite/BUYfUF2
-Reddit: www.reddit.com/r/CinemaSins/
-Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com/book
-Instagram: www.instagram.com/cinemasins/
-TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@official_cinema_sins
All Comments (21)
-
The Harkonnens boldly attacked the Atreides, this was no secret there. The "big secret" that the great houses cant know is how the Emporer is involved.
-
Firing lasers into shields creates a thermonuclear explosion on either, or both, ends, sort of randomly. That’s why they waited to use them on the crawlers until the shields were down. Is this explained only in the book? Yes. Is it therefore worth a cinema sin? Yeah, sure. Is it cool they actually understood the lore? Also yes.
-
The depiction of Geidi Prime was a monumental triumph of cinematography. The greyscale was otherworldly, spooky and alien, saved massively on set design costs, and adeptly sent the message that Harkonnen culture is rigidly black and white.
-
Dune has Spice, Rebel Moon had grain (aka everything nice) , all we need is a sci-fi property based around sugar to have the Powerpuff Girls trifecta
-
“She’ll come to understand” CinemaSins: “post nut clarity?” This might just be my favorite sin ever
-
I love how Feyd heard "May thy knife chip and shatter" and instantly looked like; "holy shit, that's the coolest thing I've ever heard." 😂
-
"How do you stop a sand worm?" That's the neat part. You don't. You aim for a large sand dune, crash through it and jump off. Also, if you haven't sufficiently tired out the worm, it will be pissed and come back and attack you. But if you ride it for far enough it will be too tired and will just go under the sand to get away.
-
Would it have been inappropriate for Lady Jessica to ask the Fremen Reverend Mother, "Can you make me a sand-witch?"
-
That whole Feyd-Rautha colosseum segment was so damn sick in IMAX; The music, the energy, the EVERYTHING. 30 sins removed! But still bro imma need you to sin Eight Legged Freaks
-
6:05 - Paul and Chani's Love Theme that plays in this scene and repeats at the end when Chani leaves is truly a wonderful piece of score. Hans Zimmer deserves all the sins off
-
Sin off for doing the math for the 2075th Olympiad at 18:26. BUT. Add a sin because the Dune calendar is AG, after guild, not AD/CE. 10191 would actually correspond to 23,352 AD, which would be the year of the 5,365th Olympiad. Look, if you can be pedantic, so can the Dune nerds. 🤣
-
Hard to explain in a movie, easy in the books. The Atreides became defiant to the Bene Gesserit order when Lady Jessica defied her orders to bear a daughter to Leto. The Bene Gesserit had been breeding the Atreides and the Harkonens for generations to create the Kwisadtz Haderach, and Jessica pissed it all away because Leto wanted a boy and she wanted him happy. It had nothing to do with the emperor until Paul was coming of age, which is when they moved to Arrakis.
-
"It's been over 2 hours...I think we all have to take a ducal signet"... Well played 🤣
-
Can’t believe they didn’t take sins off for the Lisan al-Gaib scene (you know the one). The way Paul uses his powers to take control of the religious Fremen was very chilling and Timothée’s performance was incredible, not to mention it is one of the most thematic scenes in the franchise.
-
12:26 Cinema Sins sin, they incorrectly dated this movie as being 8000 years in the future, when in reality the year 10,191 is how long it’s been since the formation and monopolization of the Spacing Guild, which would occur in about 8000 years, so dune is really about 20k years in the future
-
Paul Atreides Speech really deserves a sin off. The tension was so good, I wanted stand out and said, 'lisan al gaib' too!
-
No sin off for Geidi prime and Pauls 2 speeches is criminal
-
5:38 that is how shield weapons were developed. Any fast projectile will bounce away. That's why they have missile-like weapons that slow down right before they contact he shield and slowly push their way through. It is both explained and exemplified (during the Harkonnen attack on the Atreides) in the first movie.
-
Biggest sin of this movie: The popcorn buckets.
-
7:46 "That's not hope!! Tony Start was able to build this in a cave with a pile of scraps!!"
