How to NOT Preach to Audiences (Writing Advice)

Theme is tough to understand and tough to teach. I hope today's video helped, and if you want me to do future videos on the topic of Theme, let me know.

When the characters talk to the audience and not each other, it’s preaching

Sometimes, a theme emerges organically without being planned by the writer.

My favorite movie on the point of showing a counter-argument to the movie's own theme (or lesson, if you want to look at it that way) is Princess Mononoke. The movie has a strong conservation theme, but there is a large chunk of the movie showing how the industrialization of the town is giving purpose and meaning to the lives of many people who would be dead, discarded, or abused otherwise. It made it very clear there is no easy answer and things will turn very ugly no matter which side "wins".

I love the theme in "The Hobbit" & "The Lord of the Rings." The idea that greatness and heroism can come from anywhere, and doesn't only belong to the strong warriors.

That dinner scene in Jurassic Park really is a great example of how to explore theme through dialogue!

A theme that permeated in my head throughout this entire video was the perspective on one's past depicted in Pixar's "UP." At the start, the protagonist, Carl Frederickson is bitter, unhappy, and an overall loose nail in his community due to his unwillingness to let go of the life he used to have; the missed opportunities that haunt him throughout the entire movie. A character who starts in a similar place is the antagonist, Charles Muntz, who similarly refuses to let go of his old life; how he's willing to sacrifice anything to achieve a shadow of his former glory. Both characters end up choosing two different paths by the end of the movie. They never have a scene where they outright argue that their viewpoint is better. Rather, they clash until one falls. Frederickson chooses to live for the future, while Muntz ends up dying for the past.

Another cool thing about Jurassic Park is that when it's clear that Malcom has won the debate and Hammond has lost, Hammond has that line about only the lawyer being on his side, which reminds us that he's not the bad guy and doesn't see himself as the bad guy! It's a good idea to see the nemesis of your side of the theme in the story as still being the hero of his or her OWN story!

Ian Malcolm’s “whether or not they should” speech at the table in Jurassic Park will forever be my favorite character dialogue in a movie. Still gives me chills to hear it.

Everyone in Hollywood should take a course on this from you.

4:43, for instance, in the Emperor’s New Groove, Emperor Kuzco is a Narcissist and his ego creates several problems for him that he can only solve by learning humility

A massive theme that I really enjoyed in godzilla minus one was the theme of forgiveness. Not just forgiving other people (like when the protagonist is forgiven by the mechanic at the end because he shows him how to eject) but also forgiving yourself. It's something I know can be very difficult to do, and showing how difficult it is through your protagonist, I think, is a great idea

You're the only writing advice channel I get actively excited by when I see a new upload. Thanks for all the hard work. 👍

I think one theme I find a lot of writers get so easily wrong and so often very preachy is the Power of Friendship. Don't get me wrong: I love that theme, but so many stories boil it down to 'person has friends and is therefore better/stronger than someone who doesn't', which is not only bizarre but also vague and arguably harmful in certain scenarios. It's one that's easily failed on any level, but especially in stories aimed at a younger audience. Which is why I was surprised when I played the first Mega Man Star Force game, where I went into it not expecting a well-written plot of any kind, but this had also become my favourite example of the theme. And I think it does this by subverting a general expectation on the theme of friendship -- by showing, instead, how relationships can HARM people. Geo is an angsty teenager who doesn't go to school because of the trauma of his father's disappearance, who later is forced into working with a criminal alien who may know what happened to his father. Both of these protagonists are loners who have a hard time trusting others because of their respective pasts, but are forced to work together because they each need something from the other. In the story's case, they need each other to combine into the titular Mega Man to survive against the other invading aliens come to their world to reek havoc -- and those aliens can only do so by possessing other humans, like what his alien partner did with him. Throughout the story, Geo encounters other characters who are hurt by their relationships: a scientist whose invention was stolen by his most trusted friend, a teacher whose peers alienated him, a student who only felt they were worth something until they stopped being useful to their friends, a person who was abandoned by their family. All of these people had something in common: they were hurt because they had relationships, because they opened themselves to others. It's always making a counter-argument as to why Geo staying a loner is not a bad thing, and it's saying that just by the simple fact of HAVING connections with others, you are always open to being hurt and betrayed. I found that pretty bold for a game aimed at children to be saying.

The core for not being preachy for me is to show how the moral you want to tell is improving the character's life. Or alternatively, how not adhering to that moral is worsening the character's life. If you can't do that, you might not have a leg to stand on with your idea.

One of my favourite stories is Coco (by Pixar, 2017), a story about a boy who travels to the land of the dead hoping to meet his hero and become a famous musician. The theme is "Nothing is more important than family." Each character has a different take on it, but only those who embrace the theme succeed.

Im like... 15 but want to write better and I havent even written any actual book yet, but obviously I have way too many ideas and complicated themes and i dont even have the experience so these vids are helpful lol

My favorite theme in any story is redemption/second chances. I love seeing a character who messes up royally become genuinely repentant and figure out how to obtain that forgiveness their soul craves. Whenever I do anything with this theme, I tend to show one who does redeem themselves, and another who has that chance, but forsakes it through pride or some other reason.

My favorite theme is redemption, which is definitely evident in Avatar: The Last Airbender.

I think the theme of vengeance vs justice was done very well in Batman Mask of the Phantasm. Andrea and Batman both experienced tragedies that ruined their bright futures. To get over his tragedy Batman saves people from criminals, his methods aren't perfect but they let him keep his humanity. Andrea on the other hand uses the tragedy as an excuse to murder people and in the end it leaves her empty.