Pulse Tube Cryocooler - Part 2 (-75C)

919,149
0
Published 2022-12-27
Part 1:
   • Pulse Tube Cryocooler - Part 1  

This is the second part of my video series on attempting to build a Pulse Tube cryocooler. I managed to make significant progress by removing the linear motor and using a conventional rotary motor with a large gear reduction ratio and a flywheel to produce the larger forces needed for higher compression ratios.

For pistons, I used pneumatic actuators. I evaluated a 25mm bore and a 40mm bore piston, both with a 50mm stroke. Pneumatic actuators have more friction than conventional pistons due to their rubber lip seals, but theoretically have zero blowby, so they hold pressure, which makes them more effective for low frequency applications.

Here are some specifications for the cooler:

Pipe diameter: 18mm
Regenerator Length: 30mm
Regenerator Material: Fine steel wool
Pulse Tube Length: 100mm
Flow resistance source: 1/8 NPT needle valve
Inertance Tube Length: 10' (~3m)
Inertance Tube Diameter: 4.4mm
Buffer Tank Volume: 2L
Piston Swept volume (25mm): 23CC
Piston Swept volume (40mm): 57CC
Compression Ratio (25mm): 1.4
Compression Ratio (40mm): 2.0
Maximum Frequency: 15 Hz
Motor KV: 750
Motor Voltage: 16V
Motor reduction ratio: 5:1
Flywheel moment of Inertia: 0.012 kgm^2
Maximum recorded temperature drop below ambient: -91C
Lowest recorded temperature: -75C

I think with some more optimization, this system can probably reach -100C, although without helium or hydrogen as a working fluid, I think it's unlikely that I'll reach cold enough temperatures to liquefy oxygen/nitrogen.

In part 3 of this video, I'll do more investigation into hot-end heat exchanger design, regenerator design, and the effect of increasing the power density of the system by pressurizing it. I'll also be comparing the pulse tube performance to a similar spec alpha stirling cooler.

Links for parts:
Motor:
www.amazon.com/dp/B084QCLTM1?psc=1&ref=ppx_yo2ov_d…

25: and 40mm pistons:
www.amazon.com/gp/product/B082FW5XKS/ref=ppx_yo_dt…

www.amazon.com/dp/B08YYQZ5CQ?ref=ppx_yo2ov_dt_b_pr…

Music Used:
Kevin MacLeod - Lobby Time
Kevin MacLeod - Groove Groove

All Comments (21)
  • I've read through the comments and thought I'd address a few of them: -The 40mm piston is probably not optimally matched to the pulse tube geometry, since i optimized it for higher frequencies on the 25mm piston -For part 3 or 4 i'll probably try using Hydrogen as a working gas. It has a lower specific heat ratio than helium, but the highest thermal conductivity of any gas, so I should see an increase in performance as long as all the components are sealed well enough to avoid leakage -For part 3 I'll be looking at heat exchangers with multiple heat pipes and water cooling, as well as single tubes packed with copper wool. -I do intend to evaluate a segmented regenerator with polymer "heat breaks" to slow down axial conduction losses by breaking the continuity of the metal mesh -For higher pressures and lower temperatures, I'll be replacing the PVC with stainless steel to avoid explosion hazards. -The ESC has flyback diodes across the H-bridge MOSFETs, so any back-current from the flywheel after motor shutoff should be dissipated through those. -Multiple stages might be neccesary to reach LN2 temperatures with a DIY setup. Pulse tubes can be staged by connecting a much smaller pulse tube to the output of the compressor's aftercooler and thermally anchoring the second heat exchanger to the cold end of the first stage. Pulse tubes used for liquefying helium/hydrogen typically have 3 or 4 of these stages and can reach single-digit kelvin temperatures
  • @Aeogenia
    This is by far, the most interesting video project recommended by YouTube in a long time. Great explanation and accurate presentation. Amazing work, keep up the good work. Hope to see -200C in a while :)
  • This is fascinating. The first DIY cryocooler that works sufficiently This is the first DIY project reaching really low temperatures without complicated multistage refrigerant stages.
  • That's some seriously impressive data analysis and scientific method for a simple prototype! Great work - subscribed!
  • When cleaning wire wool up wrap the magnet in a rag so you can separate the captured steel wool from the magnet to dispose. Great to see an explanation of why gas-gas heat exchangers are hard to design!
  • @odw32
    The clarity & detail in your explanations is absolutely amazing, the collected data and visualizations really help to make this more intuitive. You're a great teacher!
  • This is the best thing that YouTube has sent my way in a LONG time. Thank you so much for the amazingly well made video, and I can't wait for the next part!
  • @hectorgarcia1326
    I love how far diy projects have come since the early days of YouTube a decade ago which were 90% LED projects keep up the good work
  • this is incredible you are the only youtuber that shows how to make a cryocooler keep this up
  • The use of the scaling exponents to predict the behaviour, along with the brute force empirical parameter sweep was beautiful ❤️ I wanted to click like so many times in this video but sadly I am limited to just one. This is so beautiful.
  • I just want to say that in terms of video produciton, you've done an excellent job in the treatment of the calculations and design considerations. You've somehow kept your explanations concise without glossing over anything big, and made it accessible without dumbing it down. Your channel is the best one Youtube has recommended me in a long time.
  • @TopiasKorpiTK
    You could try to improve regenerator performance by using several "sub-regenerators" to prevent heat conduction axially. In practice, instead of making one blob of steel wool, make several and stack them inside the tube.
  • Love this series, seriously. I feel like I understand now how “real” engineering is done. Keep the videos coming!
  • @un65tube
    I more or less stumbled by accident over your videos, but the subject is very fascinating and they are one of the best youtube videos I ever saw up to now that combine practical use with scientific background. Wish my scool lessons in physics or thermodynamic would have been so interesting! As already said by others, you would be a very good teacher! Many greetings from Germany and all the best for upcoming 2023! 😃
  • Awesome video. I have been intrigued by pulse tube coolers since I heard about it on JWST, so to see a functional DIY build is astounding. Great work, looking forward to part 3!
  • @Rocketkid2121
    This is super cool, I went down a rabbit hole of research into cryocoolers about 6 months ago but never found anyone else doing it DIY. I'm glad you took it to the next step and built it!
  • Fantastic progress!!! I admire your bravery to take on such a challenging problem. Can't wait for part 3. Thank you so much! 😘
  • @EricGardnerTX
    So, I don't comment often, but you are fantastic. This is such a great example of scientific and data driven innovation. Finding ways to isolate, measure and iterate individual components is the name of the game, and you have done it wonderfully.
  • @JuniorJunison
    What a magnificent video. I love how well you are keeping track of all the variables and then plotting them on a graph, it's a very nice tool to have when trying to optimize such a system. Well done.
  • @1weck1
    The explanations, calculations, and even concept presentation in this video is top notch. I’m learning and enjoying it