Claudia’s Timeline Explained | What is the Loophole? | Dark Netflix Season 3 Explained

266,767
0
Published 2020-07-27
In the weeks since Dark wrapped up, one of the most requested videos I’ve seen is one explaining Claudia’s timeline. This gets especially complicated when you ask the question - how did Claudia discover the loophole and the origin world? Why did she discover it now in this cycle?

In this video, I recap Claudia’s entire timeline and try my best to answer these questions! If you’re mainly interested in those questions and don’t need to revisit Claudia’s full timeline, use the chapter markers below to skip ahead:

TIMELINE
0:00 Intro
1:42 1953 - 1954: Claudia’s childhood
3:15 1986: Claudia begins work at the nuclear plant
4:52 1987: Claudia is visited by her older self and begins time traveling
9:12 2020: Claudia survives the apocalypse
10:54 2040 - 2052: Claudia kills Other Claudia and becomes Older Claudia
15:25 2019, 1986, 1953: Older Claudia’s first round of time travel
17:28 2053: Older Claudia tells Adam the truth and talks to her younger self
18:55 2020, 1987, 1954: Older Claudia’s second and final round of time travel

21:01 WHAT IS THE LOOPHOLE?
27:34 HOW CLAUDIA “USED THE LOOPHOLE”
30:02 HOW CLAUDIA DISCOVERED THE LOOPHOLE AND THE ORIGIN WORLD

Take a look and let me know if you have any other questions / topics you'd like to see me cover in more Dark videos!

Just because Dark is over, doesn't mean we're done talking about it! Make sure to subscribe for more Dark talk and coverage of other great shows!
youtube.com/onetakevids/?sub_confirmation=1

If you'd like to support the channel and make it possible for us to put out more videos like this one, please consider signing up at our Patreon!
www.patreon.com/OneTakeVids

#Dark #DarkSeason3 #Netflix

All Comments (21)
  • @pratikraut6354
    GoT : we are the greatest TV show of all time. Claudia : hold my Gretchen.
  • @hjsimmer1742
    How in the world did the creators do all this? It's absolutely incredible. Intricate, original, mind-bending, genius.
  • @guyjperson
    Why does nobody mention that Claudia is apparently an avid rappeller. She's able to enter AND exit a sheer drop cave in business heels and a pantsuit, using rappelling gear she must have had in the car. The woman is multi talented
  • @Rafael-du2yr
    This video is what every dark fan didn’t know they needed. “We can change a grain of sand. And with that, the whole world.”
  • In my opinion, Claudia Tiedemann’s story was the most interesting and tragic of all time. She saw the death of her father, daughter, and her mother perhaps. I loved Claudia throughtout all 3 seasons, and wanted more of her!
  • @Kira1Lawliet
    The ending of Dark proved that no matter how convoluted or complex your story is, you CAN make a satisfying ending provided you put in the work to figure it all out beforehand and have clarity of purpose. Lookin' at you GoT and Lost.
  • @jamesrobson4894
    This was extremely thorough and very helpful! I have one tiny detail to add however. I noticed, quite by chance, that we see ONE scene twice, as in the same moment in two cycles. 1986 Claudia walking into her office where older Claudia is already sat down. Now, this could just be a slight continuity error, but if so it’s the only one in the series I noticed. When we see the scene first, young Claudia walks in and gretchen runs to old Claudia, and the rest follows. In the compilation scene in season 3 episode 7, in what is meant to be THE SAME MOMENT, Old Claudia stands up as young Claudia walks in and says ‘hello Claudia’. This NEVER happened in the ‘first’ cycle but did in this one, thus I conclude THIS was the moment she told her younger self about the origin world which fits your ‘slinky’ theory, OR she just gave her a little more information, and thus the conversation is different each time and not identical. Several cycles later, Claudia knew enough thanks to this spoon feeding from her older self to use the loophole, tell Adam and break the cycle. Edit: Just checked the two scenes side by side again, and Gretchen is no where to be seen in the 3x7 scene while she is clearly visible running into the room in the 2x2 scene! So now we know there are clear differences, there are only 2 possibilities; either it’s a continuity error as they reshot the scene and forgot to match the dialogue or have Gretchen there, OR it’s intentional because this meeting was different to all the infinite ones before it, meaning Claudia broke cause and effect and told her younger self in this new scene (3x7) about the third world and the loophole and what to do to break the cycle.
  • @JackGames212
    That makes a lot of sense and is the clearest explanation of how Claudia discovers the loop yet, great video
  • Adam presents as a stoic and unemotional character that seems to know everything and nothing surprises him… Older Claudia is the only character that showed Adam something he didn’t previously know! The only time Adam was ever showed to be surprised was when Claudia met him. She’s like the Gandalf of Dark.
  • It seems Claudia and Regina were part of the origin world because they had real ascendents. Perhaps because of this Claudia was able to make decisions outside of 'destiny' She realised she and Regina would ultimately have life outside of the circle and that might have made the decision to end everything easier
  • @zren16
    I genuinely loved the visualization of time travel through a slinky! It really made it easier to understand the actions done by Claudia.
  • @AMMU-dg9wq
    Basically Claudia was hooking up with her own great great grand son(Tronte)... (Claudia & Bernd—>Regina Regina & Boris—> Bartosz Bartosz & Silja—>Agnes Agnes & Unknown—>Tronte)
  • @Snoogen11
    Only watched Dark recently, binged the whole thing, such great writing, I will say that Claudia is probably my favourite character. She's playing 5D chess, whilst everyone else is only worried about going forwards or backwards.
  • the morale of the tv show Dark: nothing is changeable the future is written.... oh, actually it is changeable for a happy ending.
  • I like to think that the “usual cycle” is a strange attractor. (Feel free to look that up as an important aspect of chaos theory.) In brief: there are always tiny variations in a chaotic system, but they tend to lead back to almost the same pattern. For instance planets in our solar system dance in orbit that are getting tugged in slightly different directions every year from the differing positions of the other planets and wandering asteroids and comets, and the slow changes in their own precession and axial tilts and lunar orbits etc. yet the overall pattern of the solar system has been stable for a billions years or more. Which doesn’t mean it always leads to the same cycle. Sometimes the slight variation happens to pull something just far enough to alter how things proceed from there in a significant way that can cascade into changes that form a completely different result, like planets colliding or slingshotting out of the solar system. In Dark, we get to see the final loop, where an older Claudia convinces younger Claudia there is a way to save Regina. This “deflects” younger Claudia, like a planet that drifts close enough to one of its neighbors to start a chain of altering orbits. We watch younger Claudia breaking free of the usual pattern, figuring out how to change things and finally explaining not just to Marta and Jonas but ultimately to Adam that the cycle can and will end now, forever.
  • @kunk8789
    Claudia to Claudia: We will watch your career with great interest
  • @parthkhare9960
    This is definitely the maximum effort ever taken by anyone for a series or a film, heck it even instructors do not take as much time in explaining course content, many thanks my friend!
  • @shankysays
    Awesome. Do this for every major character of dark. This will help understanding dark much better