A Star Trek Fan Production: "The Lost Starship" | Tales From The Neutral Zone |

I sit here stunned by what I just saw. This is perhaps the most amazing fan film I've seen to date. To say well done to everyone involved just seems inadequate because well, it is. Everything about it was simply perfect.

Now THAT was a story not done very often in the ST Universe, Avalon or any other. Well executed. Very well done. God Speed USS Cherokee.

One of the reasons why this is so so good, is the casting is superb. You got the right people for the right roles, and they played those roles well.

TOTALLY UNEXPECTED! I have to admit I sat in stunned silence for a few moments at the end. Very well done!! Here is to the crew of the Cherokee. SALUTE!

When something is well written and played out perfectly especially the special effects it just seems to go by to fast congratulations to everyone.

Wow, this episode was so unexpected. I had no idea what was happening or where the episode was going. But that ending.... so somber and moving. Well done, well done. This episode was impressive and the music selection was so good. One of the best Star Trek fan episodes anywhere.

when the xo said “now”, it sent chills down my spine. best episode yet!!!!!

Well done Avalon! The spirit of Star Trek lives on with you and all involved. ❤🖖

Vic coming back is a VERY welcome thing to see! VERY well done!

Vig Mignola is enjoying himself as a Klingon lol great stuff

War is hell; even when it's a cold one! ... And casualties are incurred no less costly and tragically. Such is the nature of sentient conflict. Unofficially, the crew of the U.S.S. Cherokee died in the line of duty; having given their full measure, in service to the Federation. . . . This was certainly an unexpected ending to an unexpected chain of events. It was a fast-pacing episode, and certainly heartbreaking, but a ground breaking episode for the folks at Avalon and Neutral. I feel like mourning. Congratulations. 💔

That was a breathtaking episode in the best tradition of Star Trek TOS. Bravo!

I never usually comment on non canon Star Trek - but this was a story idea worthy of the original series. Great job

That was really, really good. Some of the better acting in a Trek fan film, good special effects, and characters acting with understandable motivations.

A noble sacrifice. The essense of good drama and good Trek. Thank you!

This is the best fan story I’ve ever seen. I was riveted the entire time. Sometimes the only decisions are hard ones and there is no happy ending.

One of the best episodes yet!

I have no words for how well done this film is. I'd love to see a sequel where this crew could be saved through time travel intervention

Damn! This was such a Brilliant & Sad story! Well done to everyone involved in the production,R.i.P to the crew of the USS Cherokee,"We barely Got to Know,Her"

Wow, best Fan Film I have seen since Star Trek Continues ended, great job Vic and crew! You made me care about a crew I never knew existed 20 minutes ago and brought a tear to my eye.