Lego Propellers in Water (worst to best)

1,248,538
0
2024-04-13に共有
22 Lego propellers are tested in a water-filled container. Which one provides the most thrust? Enjoy!

2 non-Lego propellers are also tested for comparison.

Test method: a Lego Buggy motor (5292c01) and 7V input voltage. A weight scale measures the thrust in grams. Multiple gear ratios (from 1:25 to 5:1) and both directions of rotation are tested for each propeller. The test bench is explained in detail starting at 1:46.

Note: the list of gear ratios shown from 3:22 to 3:50 are incorrectly presented as inverse ratios. Sorry about that.

The results can be read in my blog:
brickexperimentchannel.wordpress.com/2024/04/13/le…

0:00 propellers worst to best
1:00 RESULTS CHART
1:46 TEST BENCH
4:22 TEST PROCEDURE
5:44 6041 Propeller 3 Blade 3 Diameter with Axle Hole
6:08 4745 Propeller 2 Blade Twisted
6:40 92842 Propeller 3 Blade 5 Diameter
7:12 non-Lego boat propeller - Joysway 2-blade P1.4x40mm 83 series
7:51 30332 Propeller 3 Blade 9 Diameter
8:21 4751c Propeller 4 Blade 13 Diameter without Studs
9:02 2952 Propeller 2 Blade 9 Diameter
9:27 64683 Technic, Panel Fairing 3 Small Smooth Long, Side A
10:10 Lego liftarm propeller 2-blade 14x9 45-deg
11:05 18592 Propeller 3 Blade 13 Diameter (Ninjago Airjitzu)
11:39 41325 Propeller 4 Blade, for Flying Model Helicopter
12:26 2740c01 Technic Propeller 3 Blade with Gear 24 Tooth
13:10 non-Lego drone propeller Diatone Bull Nose 4 x 4.5
13:51 89509 - Propeller 1 Blade 14L with Two Pin Holes and Four Axles
14:41 COMPARISON TEST: 2 vs 4 blades
14:58 COMPARISON TEST: short vs long blades
15:23 COMPARISON TEST: 30 vs 45 vs 60 pitch angle
15:49 COMPARISON TEST: narrow vs wide blades

Music:
Heaven and Hell - Jeremy Blake
   • Heaven and Hell - Jeremy Blake  

コメント (21)
  • @BeTheGr8
    Just straight into action. No intro, no sponsors, no bs. Love these kinds of channels
  • @drake52
    the fact that you are testing propellers makes me wonder if you are planning on revisiting your Lego submarine.
  • It would have been cool to only have the audio from the under water camera, that way you could hear the noise difference between the small and large propellers. In both watecraft and aircraft, small propellers have the trade-off of making more thrust per unit-area, but being significantly louder. That is one of the main reasons that fighter jets are so much louder than giant passenger aircraft despite having a fraction of the engine power, and why nuclear submarines utilize HUGE propellers that spin very slowly.
  • @koray8820
    top tier data analysis, im fully satisfied
  • Gramms per Watt would have been useful, but with the gears you also arrived the sweet spot for that motor. Although "static thrust" numbers could be very different to those when boat and prop are both moving fast through water
  • @FailRaceFan
    I love these kinds of videos. Good old empirical science. Test a bunch of stuff, note the result, analyse, learn. Great resource when making boats, planes and helicopters.
  • While I enjoy your build-up-to-the-best-bit style, I want to commend you for the intellectual honesty in getting directly to the showing off all the variations in this large-dataset case which otherwise might have had a very long build-up; not a second wasted, and once you'd shown the most clickbaity part of the video, you investigated each case further. Very respectful of your audience's time, thank you. 🙂
  • @lwpeden5
    I loved the freeze frame on each propeller followed by their dimensions. Made me feel like I was watching a heist flick where all the characters with special abilities are being introduced.
  • @rekire___
    My man trying to teach us mechanical engineering and thinking we wouldn't notice
  • @torpid5092
    Anybody else find this really weirdly relaxing? Just a quiet video with no dialogue and some experimenting
  • @KiriMantiss
    Had to stop and re-watch at 0:20 . I legit had thought it was a comically edited failure because of how smooth that piece just gently sank down. Love watching allt he test and trials you come up with. Keep up the awesome work!
  • @j-7005
    He is studying for the next Submarine!
  • @IdealIdeas100
    its crazy how much more power some of the much smaller ones put out in comparison to the larger ones
  • As propellers are tested at zero forward speed it is more useful to be compared in term of "figure of merit"(thrust/shaft power)
  • @e1woqf
    Next we need to know which design is the most efficient: thrust vs. power draw BTW: good work!
  • @JoXDDFive
    your videos are fantastic, from the editing, building puzzles solved to the top tier data analysis all in an easy to understand presentation WITHOUT saying a word!!!