Evil Leafy's Hidden Secret

vote for your favorite bfdi episodes! forms.gle/5tVJtECGM2E92oH98

When asked about why Evil Leafy isn’t in BFB, Cary said that they can’t really explain what happened to her, meaning that the Huang twins know what happened to Evil Leafy, but they most likely won’t reveal Evil Leafy’s fate until IDFB returns. My theory is that in IDFB, Pin wanted Roboty to be free so that they could use his red pigment to make her red again, and of course by BFB Pin is red again, but if that did happen, wouldn’t Roboty be white now, so I believe that eventually, they decided to capture Evil Leafy and use her to make Roboty red again, this is evidenced by the fact that Roboty can teleport to that plain in BFB 2, which Might indicates that in obtaining Evil Leafy’s pigment gave Roboty her powers, it does feel like a stretch, but it is plausible.

I always thought EL was Leafy representing Leafy's awful mental state at the time.

They are definitley more than two completely different characters that's for sure. Them being actually the same person makes a lot of sense too, but I feel like they are two different characters connected in some spiritual way, like when Leafy is going through something bad Evil Leafy attacks the people that hurt her as a way of protecting Leafy. This would explain why Evil Leafy was one of the characters in the BFDI debut while Leafy was also a contestant at the same time.

Interesting theory. Now that BFDIA is being continued hopefully we get to know more about Evil Leafy

Speaking of BFDIA, heres a little fun fact: so you see how BFDI has a hidden message through its episodes that eraser hinted off, first line of the first episode, second line of the second episode, and so on when BFDIA was canceled, it only left us with the first 6 parts (as a few years ago jnj posted the BFDIA 6 deleted scenes) saying "Dont try that thing again because" but, with the release of BFDIA 7, the message is now "don't try that thing again because IT" showing that jnj hasnt forgotten about the hidden message.

Nice theory. However, there’s one thing that debunks it. Evil Leafy was spit out of Flower WHILE Leafy was at the HPRC during BFDIA 5A (timestamp: 3:37). So there’s no way that Evil Leafy is Leafy. And, sure, she could’ve teleported back into Flower, but that would mean that the other contestants would see her do so, since they were right in front of Leafy when they recovered them.

i personally think that evil leafy was extracted to give pin her red color back. that's why pin is red again and why leafy cant turn evil anymore. in bfb 28 leafy is having a breakdown she isn't used to being mean she usually has a safety mechanism to handle that...evil leafy. but without it and for the sake of everyones safety evil leafy was removed and all that's left behind is her instinct meaning leafy will do very out of character things as a coping mechanism.

According to BFDI 25, Leafy tried to be evil but eraser and pin stopped her. meanwhile in BFDIA 1 Leafy is at yoyleland being metal and Evil Leafy was a eliminated contestant who escaped.

The fact he used ONE music at the start I dont have problem with that its just show how talented Cheesy Hfj also AMAZING theory keep it going!!!

The fact Evil Leaft is creepy

In BFDIA 7, Evil Leafy fell into water, which she wouldn’t cross in BFDIA 6, which means she might have been disintegrated, and that’s why she was hiding in a hotel shown in BFDIA 6

Really nice theory but it does debunk some things such as no contestant ever teleporting when roboty’s movements are mysterious but I do have a theory on my own about evil leafy here it is Theory: who is evil leafy? And why does she exists? Well my theory is that yk leafy how she’s always nice and all? And she’s never mean well the thing that explains it is leafy used to be normal and got mad or was mean to everyone some time to time but then she was a bit to mean and rude to other people to the point her entire life everyone hated her because of how mean she was so then she decides to separate her evilness from her probably from yellow faces factory and then she uses a device to remove her evil inners from her self and now she is a nice character but she still has some trauma and in bfdiA she was left alone in the darkness depressed which made her upset and just wanted to live alone and isolated from everyone meanwhile evil leafy roamed around in bfdiA and idfb to kill people then after some time living alone we see in bfb that leafy said to firey “why did u recover me all those years ago?” Which most probabaly happened in idfb since she’s a contestant and we see her at the end of the episode post credits however she is still metal which means that she ate YOYLEBERRYS anywho evil leafy is just leafy’s past evil stuff that’s all!

I disagree, I think evil leafy is a manifestation of leafy’s anger, instead of being the same person. I believe the more hatred leafy feels, more powerful evil leafy becomes. It’s already established that evil leafy has powers no one else has, one of these powers could be being able to revive herself. Firey couldn’t have recovered leafy in bfdia 4 because otherwise we would have seen leafy before bfdia 6 because we see evil leafy in bfdia 6, and in idfb leafy is still in yoyle land, a theory I have is that firey recoverd leafy in yoyle land and the other contestants punished him by putting him in the cage. If evil leafy and leafy were the same person, then there’s a chance the contestants would have known, which doesn’t make sense because then they would have been more scared of leafy but they aren’t.

Evil Leafy is more leafier than Leafy and these leaves 🍃

2:33 "I'm glad that im not to needey"

With BFDIA's continueation we might get some more Evil Leafy lore.

My theory is that the leafy detector wasn't a detector at all. When leafy was zapped, a clone was created. However, the clonr was far from perfect, and it was hostile and hunted down contestants.

Maybe this evil leafy is the times when leafy is mean, gets angry, and isnt as nice as she claims. Maybe she is the reason of leafy’s horrible moments, and that the nice leafy is the true leafy

even though this theory is very accurate, my theory is that evil leafy was not leafy but an entity instead, in bfdia 6, we see an evil leafy mirror at the hotel that spawned evil leafy immediately, it feels like leafy went to that hotel and maybe SAW a different shaped evil mirror😮 but later got possesed, since leafy is joyful,evil leafy will only come if she is mad and being bullied. I guess in bfdia to bfb, they manage to split leafy and evil leafy and defeat evil leafy, if evil leafy died then the mirror is broken, if it is still alive, then evil leafy will go back to the mirror to wait for another victims.